Space News
space history and artifacts articles

Messages
space history discussion forums

Sightings
worldwide astronaut appearances

Resources
selected space history documents

Forum:Publications & Multimedia
Topic:Folio Society: A Man on the Moon (Chaikin)
Want to register?
Who Can Post? Any registered users may post a reply.
About Registration You must be registered in order to post a topic or reply in this forum.
Your UserName:
Your Password:   Forget your password?
Your Reply:


*HTML is ON
*UBB Code is ON

Smilies Legend

Options Disable Smilies in This Post.
Show Signature: include your profile signature. Only registered users may have signatures.
*If HTML and/or UBB Code are enabled, this means you can use HTML and/or UBB Code in your message.

If you have previously registered, but forgotten your password, click here.

RobertB225$ for a book I've read countless times?

A bit steep!

lspoozBut is IS a great book (although I've got three copies including the 3-Volume slipcase).

I kinda want it just for the improved illustrations.

Rick MulheirnThe Folio Society has an office in London. The book can be bought through them. Still pricey £150 it works out cheaper than getting it from the US and avoids costly customs and import charges too.
Larry McGlynnYes, I have a signed 1st edition, the Time-Life set, the paperback, the holographic edition, the comic book, the bubblegum cards, and the "everything and the kitchen sink" edition too.

But I still just bought this one, because it is such a classic book and it keeps bread on Andy's table.

btguestLooks like they have different publishers, but what are the thoughts about if this edition of "A Man on the Moon" would make a good companion to Dennis Jenkins' "Space Shuttle: Developing an Icon"? Will they be somewhat complementary to one another?
Robert PearlmanOther than both titles being excellent, they do not share much in common.

Jenkins' three volumes are a technical history. Chaikin's two volumes (in this version) is a narrative.

btguestGreat. Thanks very much, Robert!
sts205cdrI just had to order this. Thanks for the heads up, Robert.
Mike DixonTempted as well.

However, pardon my ignorance, but I have two sealed sets of the Time/Life release (no slipcover). What was the difference between that and the original?

AltidudeThanks for the heads up Robert. I ordered this as well.

I honestly don't think that there will be much difference between this and the Time Life version, which can be purchased relatively cheaply. I just think that it looks better. I do wish that it was a limited edition for this price point though. Still, I'm excited to receive it and make a real comparison.

spacehikerI received the Folio version yesterday.

Frankly I am little disappointed with it. The size of the book is a little strange, a fraction taller and quite a bit wider than the original first edition. It feels like an unhappy compromise between a standard sized hardback book and a coffee table book.

The covers are likely to wear very easily and already show some wear after having taken the book out of the protective box a handful of times. They just aren't up to scratch for such an expensive book. It would have worked far better if the covers had simply not had the photos on them and instead had an artists engraving style image on them as is common for Folio Society books.

Internally though the story is different, the paper is beautiful quality, the typeface and layout are perfect and there are lots of iconic glossy images.

Is it worth £150 UK or over $200 US dollar? In my view definitely not. It's probably worth around £80 to £100. It's a book to pick up at one of the Folio Society sales.

I have attached some images to show it in comparison to the first edition, which the Folio edition is far superior too.

GoesTo11I was about to buy this... then I noticed the small format.

For US$225, I assumed this would be a coffee-table production.

Pass.

Robert PearlmanI received my copy, as well. To me, the size makes for easier reading than having to support two sides of a large and heavy coffee table book when open.

With regards to the quality of the volumes, it arrived wrapped in wax paper, which made me think about putting on my cotton gloves before handling. But this is a book meant to be enjoyed, so I gave up on that and did not see any immediate downsides to doing so.

The layout of the volumes is fantastic and the photos are stunning. Not to say that Andy Chaikin didn't give care to the photos in the prior Time/Life edition, but it is clear he went above and beyond in this version for Folio. (He told me he spent six months working on the images alone, and it shows.)

Everyone will have their own opinion, but I am happy to add this version to my library. I would recommend it to others, especially those who do not have a copy of "A Man on the Moon."

sts205cdrI've ordered my copy. Just curious, would it be recommended to get some sort of archival slip-on dust jacket protective cover for it? Are these easy to order?
spacehikerThe potential problem with this is that the volumes fit quite tightly into the slipcase so any protective cover would need to be thin which rules out most standard slide in book covers.

For books like this I generally use Brodart archival film/covers. With a bit of folding, and use of archival tape you can make a decent protective cover for the book.

GoesTo11I'm semi-reconsidering this. Still seems overpriced to me, but obviously everyone's mileage may vary.

Question for Robert or anyone else who already has theirs: How is this edition's text divided over two volumes? Chaikin's original three-book narrative lent itself rather neatly to the Time-Life edition.

GilbertIt is an awesome edition of an awesome book.
jutrasedI too have a signed 1st edition. I met Andrew at the Brown University Bookstore (where he got his degree in Geology). But I think the price may go down in the future. Several years ago I was able to pick up many copies of the Time-Life version (some still sealed) for $12.99 a piece. I’m sure it originally sold for much more.

Contact Us | The Source for Space History & Artifacts

Copyright 1999-2024 collectSPACE. All rights reserved.





advertisement